• November 17, 2026
  • 59min 34sec

ReaShure Fed in the Feedlot: Growth, Health and Carcass Quality

Guests: Dr. Brad Johnson, Dr. Heather White, Dr. Clay Zimmerman

This episode of the Real Science Exchange Podcast was recorded live at the Florida Ruminant Nutrition Symposium, this episode of the Real Science Exchange explores how rumen-protected choline in beef cattle in beef cattle may influence growth, health, feed efficiency, marbling, and carcass outcomes as cattle spend more days on feed and reach heavier finishing weights.

Host Scott Sorrell, Director of Global Marketing at Balchem, is joined by Dr. Brad Johnson of Texas Tech University, Dr. Heather White of the University of Wisconsin, and Dr. Clay Zimmerman of Balchem.

The discussion looks beyond whether choline can affect cattle performance and asks a more practical question: Where in the beef production cycle could rumen-protected choline provide the greatest value?

Key Takeaways

  • Today’s cattle create new opportunities for targeted choline supplementation. Heavier cattle and longer finishing periods create a larger window for identifying potentially valuable supplementation periods.
  • Receiving may be one of those opportunities. Preliminary observations discussed in the episode suggest potential health benefits, but the speakers stress that these results are early and require additional research.
  • Marbling is a lifelong biological process. Intramuscular fat may be the last adipose depot to fill substantially, but the cells involved are present much earlier in life.
  • Choline’s effects could extend beyond its established roles. The panel discusses choline as a methyl donor and its involvement in lipid and glucose metabolism, while also exploring new mechanistic hypotheses.
  • A muscle-fiber hypothesis is emerging. Dr. Brad Johnson discusses a developing hypothesis that choline could influence adrenergic signaling and favor more oxidative muscle fibers. The mechanism has not been established.
  • Beef-on-dairy creates another potential value opportunity. Health, growth, efficiency, and carcass improvements could potentially create value at several points in the supply chain.
  • Mechanism matters. Understanding how choline produces observed responses could help researchers determine the right animals, production stages, doses, and durations for supplementation.
  • More research is needed. Muscle and liver biopsies, cell-culture work, receiving studies, gestational research, and evaluations later in the feeding period could help answer the remaining questions.

Episode 230: ReaShure Fed in the Feedlot: Growth, Health and Carcass Quality

Timestamps:

Choline Research in Beef Cattle: Why Revisit It Now?
The episode begins with introductions and a look back at choline research in cattle. Dr. Clay Zimmerman explains that early dairy work included unprotected choline, while the first ReaShure research in beef cattle dates to the late 1990s.

Dr. Brad Johnson discusses historical studies and how today’s cattle and feeding systems have changed. Longer days on feed, heavier carcasses, evolving marketing systems, and different economics have created renewed interest in identifying where supplementation could make the greatest difference. (00:00 – 07:28)

Could Receiving Be a Sweet Spot for Rumen-Protected Choline?
Dr. Brad Johnson describes cattle entering feedlots at heavier weights while also spending significantly more time on feed. That raises an important question: rather than feeding rumen-protected choline throughout the entire feeding period, are there specific “sweet spots” where supplementation could provide more value?

Receiving is one potential target.

Dr. Brad Johnson discusses early, anecdotal observations in which first treatments were down approximately 80% in the rumen-protected choline group, with none of those cattle pulled a second time.

The panel is careful to characterize these observations as preliminary rather than established research findings, underscoring the need for controlled studies.(07:29 – 11:51)

Marbling Starts Earlier Than You Might Think
The discussion then shifts to marbling and the biology of intramuscular fat.

Although intramuscular adipose tissue is one of the last fat depots to fill substantially with lipid, Dr. Brad Johnson explains that the cells responsible for that process are present much earlier, potentially beginning as early as mid-gestation.

That creates a broader way of thinking about marbling. Instead of viewing it strictly as a late-finishing event, management and nutrition earlier in life may influence the biological foundation needed for later marbling.

The panel considers whether receiving and the middle portion of the feeding period could represent opportunities to support marbling development while also influencing feed conversion. (11:52 – 16:56)

Choline, Liver Metabolism & Nutrient Partitioning
Dr. Heather White connects the discussion to choline’s role in liver lipid and glucose metabolism.

If choline helps support metabolic processes in the liver, the panel considers whether that could potentially spare nutrients for use by other tissues. Historical research also raises questions about possible interactions between dietary fat and choline.

These potential mechanisms remain an important area for further research, particularly when it comes to understanding fat digestion, absorption, metabolism, and nutrient partitioning. (16:57 – 22:23)

Creating Value Across the Beef-on-Dairy Supply Chain
If rumen-protected choline can consistently influence health, growth, efficiency, or carcass value, who ultimately captures that value?

The panel explores that question through the lens of beef-on-dairy production.

Dr. Brad Johnson discusses retained ownership and strategic partnerships with feedlots as possible ways to capture more value from management decisions made earlier in an animal’s life.

Backgrounding and receiving are also potential applications because calves may be dealing with transportation, dietary transitions, commingling, and other stresses during these periods. (22:24 – 27:39)

Could Choline Influence Muscle Fiber Type?
The panel moves into one of the episode’s most forward-looking questions.

Beyond choline’s recognized roles as a methyl donor and in lipid metabolism, Dr. Brad Johnson presents a developing hypothesis involving adrenergic receptor signaling and muscle fiber type.

He proposes that choline could potentially favor a more oxidative muscle-fiber phenotype. If confirmed, that could help researchers understand recurring observations involving marbling and slightly smaller ribeye areas.

Importantly, this is a hypothesis, not an established mechanism. Dr. Brad Johnson emphasizes that determining whether the pathway actually explains observed results will require additional research. (27:40 – 37:33)

What Research Could Answer the Mechanism Question?
The researchers outline several approaches that could help determine how rumen-protected choline works in beef cattle, including:

  • Muscle biopsies
  • Liver biopsies
  • Cell-culture research
  • Muscle fiber typing
  • Gestational studies
  • Metabolic measurements

Dr. Brad Johnson discusses plans to examine muscle fiber type in animals exposed to rumen-protected choline in utero.

Dr. Heather White connects the hypothesis with previous cell-culture findings involving the regulation of important gluconeogenic and lipogenic enzymes.

Together, these approaches could help move the research from documenting responses toward understanding the biological pathways responsible for them. (37:34 – 41:27)

Longer Feeding Periods Create a Bigger Window
Dr. Clay Zimmerman discusses Balchem’s continued investment in choline research and notes 42 published peer-reviewed papers around ReaShure.

Dr. Brad Johnson returns to the changes taking place within beef production. Increasing finishing weights and longer feeding periods mean producers have a larger window in which targeted supplementation strategies could potentially be applied.

He also cautions against interpreting statistical significance as the only measure of relevance. A carcass-weight response may still deserve consideration from a biological or economic perspective even when a particular experiment doesn’t reach statistical significance. (41:28 – 49:55)

What’s Next for Rumen-Protected Choline Research?
Looking ahead, Dr. Brad Johnson says understanding choline’s mechanism of action will be critical to determining where and when it can be used most effectively, whether during gestation, receiving, backgrounding, or later phases of the feeding period.

In their final takeaways:

  • Dr. Clay Zimmerman points to renewed research interest in ReaShure and beef cattle.
  • Dr. Heather White highlights consistency across dairy and beef research as researchers continue investigating choline’s metabolic effects.
  • Dr. Brad Johnson emphasizes the opportunity to better understand choline’s relationship with growth, metabolism, and animal well-being. (49:56 – End)

Join Us at the Real Science Exchange

If you enjoyed this episode, subscribe to the Real Science Exchange and share it with your colleagues in the dairy industry. That way, they can join the conversation at our virtual pub table.

Continue learning from leading researchers and dairy industry experts by registering for an upcoming Real Science Lecture Series webinar.

And don’t forget your Real Science Exchange T-shirt! Screenshot your rating, review, or subscription, then email the image to anh.marketing@balchem.com along with your shirt size and mailing address.

FAQ


What is rumen-protected choline?

Rumen-protected choline is designed to protect choline from extensive degradation in the rumen so that more can become available to the animal for absorption and metabolism.

Why is rumen-protected choline being studied in beef cattle?

Researchers are investigating whether rumen-protected choline can influence outcomes including growth, health, feed efficiency, marbling, metabolic function, and carcass performance. The panel also discusses where supplementation might provide the greatest value during an animal’s production cycle.

Could rumen-protected choline support receiving cattle?

Receiving is one potential application discussed in this episode. Dr. Brad Johnson shares promising preliminary observations involving reduced first treatments, but emphasizes that the observations are early and controlled research is needed before drawing conclusions.

How could choline affect marbling in beef cattle?

The mechanism isn’t fully established. The panel discusses choline’s known involvement in methyl donation and lipid metabolism, as well as a developing hypothesis that choline could influence adrenergic signaling and muscle fiber type in ways that may affect marbling.

When might rumen-protected choline provide the greatest value?

Potential windows discussed include gestation, receiving, backgrounding, the middle portion of the feeding period, and finishing. Determining optimal timing and duration remains an active research question.

Why could longer days on feed change how choline is used?

As cattle spend more time on feed, producers have a larger window in which targeted nutritional interventions may be applied. Rather than supplementing throughout the entire period, researchers are interested in identifying specific stages with the greatest potential response.

How could rumen-protected choline fit into beef-on-dairy production?

The panel discusses opportunities associated with health, growth, feed efficiency, and carcass outcomes. Retained ownership or coordination between calf raisers, backgrounders, and feedlots could potentially help capture value created at different stages.

ReaShure Fed in the Feedlot: Growth, Health and Carcass Quality – Transcript

Welcome and Guest Introductions (0:00)

Scott Sorrell: Good evening, everyone, and welcome to the Real Science Exchange, the podcast where leading scientists and industry professionals meet over a few drinks to discuss the latest ideas and trends in animal nutrition.

Dr. Brad Johnson of Texas Tech University will take us on a deep dive into how choline supplementation influences growth, performance, animal health, and carcass outcomes in the feedlot. Alongside him, we’ve got Dr. Heather White, who’s going to be our color commentator today, and Dr. Clay Zimmerman. They’re going to help us connect the science with real-world feeding strategies.

Clay, before we get started, I want to introduce you. It’s been a while since I’ve had you here in the co-pilot spot. Tell us real quick who you are.

Dr. Clay Zimmerman: I am the Director of Science for Balchem. I’ve been with the company for 12 years now.

Scott Sorrell: Excellent. And as I said, Dr. White is going to be our color commentator today. Say hi to everybody, Heather.

Dr. Heather White: Hi. I’m at the University of Wisconsin–Madison in the area of nutritional physiology. I’ve been here a time or two.

Scott Sorrell: Absolutely. Thanks for coming again.

Early Research on Choline in Cattle (1:11)

Scott Sorrell: Clay, people normally think of choline and ReaShure being used in dairy cattle, and yet the very first research that was done with choline was actually done with beef cattle. Maybe you want to say just a few words about that.

Dr. Clay Zimmerman: Well, let’s step back from that for a minute.

Scott Sorrell: Let’s do that.

Dr. Clay Zimmerman: The first research was done in dairy cattle with unprotected choline. A lot of research was done in the 1980s. Rumen-protected choline did not exist back then. That was done with choline chloride administered post-ruminally.

But the first ReaShure research was done with beef cattle in the late 1990s. We didn’t really know how to apply it back then. We were looking at beef feeding applications as well as dairy cattle applications.

There is quite a bit of research going back into the mid- to late 1990s looking at rumen-protected choline in beef cattle.

Scott Sorrell: And now the pendulum has swung, and we’re talking about beef again. We’ve got Dr. Brad Johnson with us today to do that. Brad, you’re going to give us a little bit of a history lesson during the presentation. Tell us what you’re going to cover.

Sponsor Message: ReaShure Precision Release Choline

Announcer: The economics of feeding ReaShure Precision Release Choline: ReaShure is fed during the transition period, and because it’s fed for such a short period of time, it costs just $15 per cow. Yet the benefits continue to generate income throughout the year.

Cows fed ReaShure produced 5 lbs more colostrum, which pays for your ReaShure investment on the very first day of lactation. Cows fed ReaShure also produce 5 lbs more milk per day, every day. That means after the first day, every day is payday.

Invest in ReaShure during the transition period and recoup your investment on the very first day of lactation. After that, you got it: payday.

Historical Studies and Changing Feedlot Practices (3:40)

Dr. Brad Johnson: Scott, thanks for having me back. It’s always a privilege, as a beef guy, to be on a dairy podcast.

What I hope to do today is give a historical lesson on what Clay just referenced. There were two key dose-titration studies done in the mid- to late 1990s: one with heifers and one with feedlot steers in Kansas and the Texas Panhandle.

What’s interesting is that, in both cases, those cattle were fed only 120 to 140 days in the feedlot. That’s one example of how our industry has shifted.

We saw nice biological responses. In one study with steers, at roughly a 22-gram, or approximately 20-gram, dose of ReaShure rumen-protected choline, they saw a 12% improvement in average daily gain. We had about a 17-lb heavier hot carcass weight in those steers.

But the economics at the time were different. That dose was probably about 10 cents per head per day over a 140-day period. The return on investment was somewhere between 1.5:1 and 3:1.

For beef feedlot managers and nutritionists, especially with non-pharmaceutical feed additives such as rumen-protected choline, they were probably a little nervous about that level of return on investment. Application probably stalled after a couple of those trials.

Then the focus shifted toward the transition dairy cow. But from a biological-response standpoint, including average daily gain and carcass quality, we saw responses. At certain doses, we also saw increased marbling. At that time, however, it came down to the cost of the product.

Scott Sorrell: You said the cattle were fed 140 days. When did supplementation start? At receiving?

Dr. Brad Johnson: Yes. These would have been typical yearling-type cattle for the 1990s. The steers might have come in at 650 to 700 lbs, and the heifers at 600 to 650 lbs.

A traditional feeding program in the High Plains at that time would bring in backgrounded calves or yearling-type cattle and feed them for 120 to 140 days. They would have started on ReaShure rumen-protected choline on day one and continued through the entire feeding period.

Scott Sorrell: Now, when we had the podcast with Dr. White, we talked about three periods where choline might be appropriate for beef cattle: prepartum, receiving, and the growing phase. How would you divide the growing phase, and where might you target supplementation?

Targeted Choline Supplementation in Modern Feeding Programs (7:29)

Dr. Brad Johnson: That’s a great point, Scott. This is what we need to think about on the beef feedlot side.

I just talked about how, in the 1990s, we fed cattle for 120 days. Today, we’ll bring in what we call backgrounded calves. I recently helped a feedlot in Nebraska put together a break-even where they were buying 950-lb backgrounded calves out of South Dakota.

Those calves were probably born in March, weaned in October or November, and already weighed around 950 lbs. They’re planning on feeding those cattle for 220 days, and those cattle will go out weighing around 1,800 lbs. That’s the reality of our industry today.

We’ve added all these days, so what I’m going to talk about is targeted application. I think that’s something you’ve done very well in the dairy industry, Dr. White, and we need to think that way on the beef side.

The reality is we probably can’t afford to feed ReaShure for 280 to 320 days in the feedlot. We need to identify what I call the “sweet spots.”

From a feedlot perspective, some very positive research out of Argentina showed significant economic and biological effects during the first 21 days on feed, during the receiving period, related to growth and health.

We’re trying to follow that up with some large-pen trials here in the United States focused on the first part of the feeding period.

Scott Sorrell: Twenty-one days again?

Dr. Brad Johnson: In the first study, they’ll actually be fed for 120 days. We’ll also be able to maintain those cattle in the same pens and look at carcass quality at harvest, even though they won’t be fed rumen-protected choline after day 120.

Receiving Phase Health, Performance and Economics (9:32)

Scott Sorrell: Just to clarify, are you going to take a snapshot around 21 days to look at health events, growth, and those kinds of outcomes?

Dr. Brad Johnson: We’re collecting data from day zero to day 120. We have initial weights, and we’ll weigh the cattle off trial at day 120.

With the feed delivery and health management computer systems these commercial feedlots have, we get weekly updates on the number of cattle pulled for sickness and on death loss. At the end, we’ll accumulate all of that.

We’ve seen some very positive anecdotal and preliminary data. And that’s all anecdotal at this point. Our first treatments are down about 80% in the rumen-protected choline group. None of those cattle have had to be pulled a second time, and death loss is very low across all treatments.

What’s happened in the beef industry is that the value of feeder cattle is so high. When day-old beef-on-dairy cross calves are bringing $1,500 to $1,600, and I’m trying to buy 475-lb cattle for another receiving trial at more than $6 per pound, or around $2,600 per head, keeping those cattle alive and reducing medicine costs is huge.

That’s what we’re really targeting on the receiving side. But growth matters too. As we start talking about carcass quality, if these cattle perform really well early in the feeding period, that sets those marbling adipocytes up to contribute to more marbling at the end.

There are a lot of ancillary benefits from getting these calves started well in the feedlot. That’s the first phase we’re targeting for application of ReaShure.

Marbling Adipocyte Development Across Life Stages (11:52)

Scott Sorrell: Talk a little bit about those marbling adipocytes. We used to think all the marbling took place in the last 30 days, but the reality is different.

Dr. Brad Johnson: Exactly. We were taught when Scott and I were undergraduates that there are several types of adipose tissue in meat animals.

Internal fat is the earliest-developing fat. Then we have subcutaneous fat, intermuscular fat, or seam fat, and intramuscular fat, which is marbling.

Intramuscular fat truly is the last adipose tissue to fill with lipid, or undergo hypertrophy. But the reality is those cells are there at birth. They may even be there by mid-gestation.

Some fetal-programming work, including Dr. White’s work feeding rumen-protected choline during the last 21 to 42 days of gestation, has affected marbling. That tells us marbling is a lifelong event.

Even though those are the last cells to substantially fill with lipid, if we’re below maintenance, the animal will pull energy out of that marbling very quickly.

I used to say the genetic potential of an animal to marble was greatest the day it was born, and everything we do thereafter could have a negative impact on marbling from a feedlot perspective.

Historical Finishing Weights vs. Modern Sweet Spots (13:37)

Dr. Clay Zimmerman: Brad, going back a little bit, today you say we’re finishing cattle at 1,800 lbs. In the late 1990s, when that original work was done with protected choline, what were they finishing at?

Dr. Brad Johnson: I’ll show some of that data today. The heifer study was done at Kansas State just before I arrived there in 2000. The average hot carcass weight of those heifers was exactly 300 kilograms, or around 660 lbs.

The outweight of those heifers was right around 1,050 lbs, which was typical back then. Both studies were also done during a time when nearly everything was marketed on a live-weight basis. Feed efficiency and feed conversion on a live basis were the primary metrics nutritionists cared about.

Today, everything is marketed on a carcass and grid basis. I just described bringing in steers weighing 950 lbs, which was almost the outweight of those old heifers.

We’ve extended days on feed, so now we have a bigger sweet spot. We need to identify these different phases, because it might be the middle of that 240-day feeding period that’s most critical for feeding ReaShure to influence carcass-quality attributes at the end.

Scott Sorrell: What’s the hypothesis for that middle section?

Dr. Brad Johnson: Maybe part of it comes from what we’ve learned at the other end. We’ve tried feeding ReaShure during the beta-agonist feeding period at the end and haven’t seen remarkable responses from a carcass-growth standpoint, although we have seen some effects on postnatal muscle development.

What I still think could be happening from a carcass-quality standpoint, especially if we’re feeding it in the receiving period, is that maybe we want to extend that into the middle part of the finishing period and look at its impacts on marbling development and feed efficiency.

Feed conversion is incredibly important on the feedlot side, just like it is on the dairy side.

I tell producers and my students that, from a profit-and-loss standpoint, the number-one determinant is what we pay for calves. Number two is what we sell the cattle for. But number three is consistently feed conversion.

I think the middle of the feeding period is where we could potentially have the most positive impact on feed conversion.

Liver Metabolism, Nutrient Sparing and Feed Efficiency (16:57)

Dr. Heather White: Can I jump in here?

Scott Sorrell: Absolutely.

Dr. Heather White: On the feed-efficiency side, I think that really aligns. We saw changes during that same kind of period in our beef-on-dairy work, but also in a beef study where we fed in utero.

When you mention that middle sweet spot, it brings me back to your discussion of when adipocytes fill for marbling.

We know from dairy work, and actually from multiple species, that choline influences lipid metabolism. It’s also influencing glucose metabolism in the liver. If that’s sparing certain nutrients so they can go to other tissues, that could be important.

If we think about when adipocytes begin filling, it would make sense for choline action to influence marbling during that middle period when fatty acids are first being deposited into those cells.

Dr. Brad Johnson: That’s a great point. The nutrient-sparing aspect could have an important impact on feed conversion as well.

If we remove the first 56 days and the final 56 days, some of these cattle still have about 150 days in the middle. That really adds up from a cost-of-gain standpoint.

We’re probably lacking research data in that area, and that’s where we need to focus. Taking care of the liver is probably crucial during that middle period.

Dr. Heather White: Especially in the ruminant animal, where lipid isn’t being made de novo in the liver like it is in some other species. We need the liver to metabolize it.

We know from some of our other work that the liver can preferentially use fatty acids or spare them. If we’re sparing them in the liver through nutrient supplementation such as choline, that could make more available for muscle.

Dietary Fat Interaction and Fat Absorption (18:59)

Dr. Brad Johnson: Dr. White just triggered a memory about that early work.

One study with heifers at Kansas State was actually a factorial design. They looked at a dose titration of tallow, with added fat levels of approximately 0%, 2%, or 4%, with and without different doses of rumen-protected choline up to 60 grams.

They actually saw a rumen-protected choline-by-fat-level interaction. I think that speaks to what Heather just described.

That data has largely been forgotten, but the higher the tallow level and the higher the choline, the better the response. That may speak to this discussion about lipid metabolism.

Dr. Heather White: Wouldn’t it be interesting to revisit that? We’ve learned so much about fatty-acid metabolism and supplementing specific fatty acids, and we have many products available today. It would be really interesting to do another factorial study and explore different fat supplementation strategies.

That work was done almost 30 years ago.

Some of it was in theses and dissertations, and some of what was published got lost in the stacks. Resurrecting some of that old research can sometimes bring new insight.

Scott Sorrell: Brad, do you think it’s possible that choline supplementation could increase fat absorption?

Dr. Brad Johnson: Potentially. That’s a little outside my wheelhouse, though. Heather may be able to address it better.

Dr. Heather White: There was some work involving bile salts because of the lipid and cholesterol interaction.

Dr. Clay Zimmerman: There was also work in some of the Arshad and Santos data. In very fresh cows, they did a fat-feeding challenge in early lactation and saw a significant improvement in fat absorption with the higher dose.

Dr. Brad Johnson: What’s interesting is that the Kansas State work also used a highest level of 60 grams. If I recall correctly, that 60-gram level only had a benefit with really high fat in the diet.

Dr. Clay Zimmerman: Sixty grams of protected product.

Dr. Brad Johnson: Yes. Similar to what you’re feeding in dairy. We probably need to go back and really dig into that data to understand it thoroughly.

Value Creation and Premium Structures for Calves (22:24)

Scott Sorrell: Does this conversation about higher dietary fat have any implications for dairy cattle?

Dr. Heather White: You should put that on your list for Adam Lock.

If we had factorial studies with choline in or out, that would be really interesting. Michigan State’s dairy doesn’t default-feed choline, so his fat studies would have been done in the absence of rumen-protected choline.

We know from his work that there are differential benefits of different fatty acids postpartum.

Scott Sorrell: Sorry to digress from beef cattle, Brad, but that’s one of the cool things about the Real Science Exchange. You never know where it’s going to go.

Dr. Brad Johnson: I think it’s important for the dairy industry to understand this. I’m saying this a little tongue-in-cheek, but any feed additive that can potentially add performance and efficiency in the feedlot allows order buyers to pay even more.

We’re paying $1,500 to $1,600 for day-old beef-on-dairy calves. If we can fine-tune feed additives that positively affect growth and carcass outcomes, feedlots can send the message back to their order buyers to pay more for calves coming off dairies. In the end, it’s a cycle that can benefit everybody.

Scott Sorrell: Let me ask you directly. If a dairy farmer is feeding choline prepartum and we know that’s going to have a positive impact on a beef-on-dairy cross all the way through carcass quality, do you see an established premium structure developing? If you’re feeding certain things prepartum, is that animal actually worth more?

Dr. Brad Johnson: There are many examples of that throughout the history of beef production.

But I think the best way for a dairy producer to take advantage of it may be retained ownership. The dairy producer could own those calves all the way through, but they don’t necessarily have to own all of them. They could partner with the feedlot.

Data is crucial for transferring that value through the supply chain.

At some point, it may become valuable to highlight not only that these calves received high-quality colostrum, but that they were also exposed to rumen-protected choline.

Dr. Heather White: Sometimes simply having a guaranteed buyer because you’re doing those best practices is valuable as well.

Choline Applications in Backgrounding Programs (26:34)

Scott Sorrell: You mentioned backgrounding. How long is that period, and is that another potential place where you might see benefits?

Dr. Brad Johnson: A lot of times, the backgrounding stage would probably overlap with what we call the receiving period.

For example, here in Florida, large ranches might early-wean calves at 90 to 120 days instead of the traditional 180 to 205 days. Those calves then go into a grower or backgrounding yard, where they’re usually fed a higher-roughage diet.

That’s also where we see the stress associated with shipping and receiving. So yes, I think rumen-protected choline could potentially have an important role during that backgrounding and receiving period.

Choline as a Second Messenger in Adrenergic Receptor Systems (27:40)

Scott Sorrell: Any other key topics you’re going to cover in your presentation that we haven’t talked about yet?

Dr. Brad Johnson: One thing I’ve become really interested in during the last couple of months is a new theory, coming more from work on the human side, that suggests choline may be more than just a methyl donor or something affecting lipid metabolism.

It may be part of a second-messenger system for adrenergic receptor signaling.

Every cell in our body has alpha or beta adrenergic receptors. Many of the growth promotants we use at the end of the feeding period, such as ractopamine, zilpaterol, and lubabegron, work through adrenergic receptor signaling systems.

We’ve seen an interesting phenomenon in much of Dr. White’s work, as well as historical work involving postnatal feeding of rumen-protected choline. We enhance marbling, but we also see an incredibly consistent reduction in the muscle hypertrophy response as measured by ribeye area, or longissimus dorsi area.

The magnitude is small, but it’s remarkably consistent.

That has everything to do with muscle fibers and muscle-fiber type. If we have more marbling, we’re probably going to have more type I myosin heavy-chain fibers, which are oxidative in nature and fit with the lipid-metabolism story.

When we use growth promotants, we tend to increase the size of myosin heavy-chain type IIx fibers. Cattle, like humans, have three predominant myosin heavy-chain fiber types.

Type I is oxidative. Type IIa can be oxidative or glycolytic, so we call it intermediate. Then we have the larger type IIx fibers, which respond most strongly to growth promotants. They’re glycolytic and rely heavily on glycogen. There’s very little marbling associated with those fibers.

Scott Sorrell: Are those the double-muscled animals?

Dr. Brad Johnson: No. Animals with a true myostatin mutation and double muscling have roughly twice as many fibers, but those fibers are predominantly glycolytic. They have essentially no marbling.

What excites me is that maybe this goes beyond methyl donors and lipid metabolism. Recent signaling work suggests choline could be a second messenger for an alpha-adrenergic receptor.

We teach students that growth promotants such as beta agonists bind to beta-adrenergic receptors. But next to the beta receptor is an alpha receptor that can antagonize the beta receptor.

My theory is that by feeding rumen-protected choline, we may be offsetting aspects of beta-receptor signaling by upregulating alpha signaling. That could cause a shift toward more oxidative fibers, which could help explain increased marbling and the small but consistent reductions in ribeye area.

The interesting thing is that we’re still able to maintain feed efficiency. Normally, we might think more lipid storage and more oxidative fibers would result in poorer feed conversion, but we don’t see that.

More oxidative fibers are also positive for end-product quality. Not only could we have more marbling, but that muscle tends to be more tender.

We don’t yet have data linking all of this. But I think the pieces are starting to line up, suggesting choline may have roles beyond being a methyl donor and affecting lipid metabolism. If it truly participates in adrenergic receptor signaling, we have an entirely new research platform to understand how it affects growth and the development of economically important tissues.

Understanding Shifts in Ribeye Area and Fiber Types (33:15)

Scott Sorrell: When I hear “smaller ribeye area,” that immediately sounds negative. Is that going to be difficult to overcome?

Dr. Brad Johnson: Not really, because the magnitude is very small.

In one trial, for example, we had a ribeye area of around 15.6 in the control and 15.3 in the rumen-protected choline group. We’re talking about a relatively small difference.

What’s notable is how consistent the response is. I’ve done enough muscle-fiber histology work to know that even a subtle shift away from the larger type IIx fibers toward smaller oxidative type I fibers could contribute to that consistent response in ribeye area.

There are many other muscles in the beef carcass, and we typically measure only the ribeye. From a red-meat-yield standpoint, we’d need research to show we’re not negatively affecting yield across the whole carcass.

But I’m excited that we may be able to maintain feed conversion while shifting toward more oxidative fibers, which could be very beneficial from a beef-quality standpoint.

Genetic Influences Across Dairy and Beef Breeds (34:50)

Scott Sorrell: Would genetics play a role? Could some animals respond better because of their muscle-fiber makeup?

Dr. Brad Johnson: That’s a great question. Dairy-influenced animals naturally have more oxidative fibers.

We’ve done a lot of work comparing Holstein steers with beef-on-dairy crosses and native beef cattle. The highest proportion of oxidative fibers in the longissimus muscle tends to be in 100% dairy-influenced animals.

It would be interesting to see whether there’s a breed interaction. In the work I’ve done with growth promotants, such as steroidal implants or beta agonists, those products generally improve growth in all animals, but the magnitude tends to be lowest in dairy-influenced animals and greatest in native beef cattle.

Maybe native beef animals would respond the most. On the other hand, Dr. White’s data would suggest responses in F1 animals too.

The consistency of the response to this product is what gets me. It’s consistently affecting marbling and ribeye size across different genetic backgrounds.

Dr. Clay Zimmerman: Brad, could you speculate what might happen in Wagyu beef?

Dr. Brad Johnson: That would be the ultimate test from a marbling standpoint. If you’re already around 30% intramuscular lipid, maybe we’re splitting hairs at that point.

Maybe the better opportunity is in animals that don’t naturally have as much propensity to marble. We’ve selected Angus genetics, especially for beef-on-dairy, for high marbling. But we also use breeds such as Charolais and Limousin, where marbling can be more challenging. That may be a better model in which to test an enhancement.

Research Approaches: Biopsies and Cell-Culture Models (37:34)

Scott Sorrell: What kind of research will it take to prove this hypothesis? It’s more than just measuring performance and output.

Dr. Brad Johnson: We’ve formed a collaboration with several scientists across the country.

In one of Dr. White’s recent studies, the animals were exposed to rumen-protected choline in utero. We fed them out, collected individual feed-intake data on a GrowSafe-type system, and took muscle biopsies about a week before harvest.

Our lab will focus on the muscle aspect. We’ll have data very soon. We already have most of the samples sectioned and ready to begin antibody work.

I’m very excited to see whether we altered the proportion of fiber types in those animals.

These animals were exposed to ReaShure in utero, more than 400 days before harvest, and yet we saw biological differences in marbling and ribeye area. The differences were small and may not have been statistically significant, but if we can demonstrate differences in muscle-fiber type, that’s a beginning.

Our lab does a lot of muscle-biopsy work, and we’ve also done liver biopsies. My focus is determining whether we can affect postnatal muscle hypertrophy.

Dr. Heather White: In that study, we also have liver biopsies. We’re hoping to look at those as well.

The idea of mechanism of action makes sense because, when I first started doing choline work, we used a cell-culture model with liver cells and found that choline influenced the regulation of key gluconeogenic and lipogenic enzymes.

Choline wasn’t itself the precursor for glucose metabolism, but it was positively influencing those pathways through regulation.

Now, having these liver and muscle samples will be important for testing these theories.

Dr. Brad Johnson: I’ve done a lot of muscle-cell-culture work throughout my career. Those trials also tend to be much less expensive than conducting a 280-day finishing trial.

We could expose muscle myotubes to different levels of choline, trying to target biologically appropriate levels, and examine fiber type, protein synthesis, and protein degradation.

We can block beta receptors or alpha receptors with antagonists and see how choline affects the response. You can test far more treatments in cell culture than in a live-animal study.

That’s something we could begin very quickly to better understand the mode of action, assuming we see differences in fiber type in Heather’s samples.

Balchem Divisions and Commitment to Research (41:28)

Scott Sorrell: Choline was discovered back in the 1920s or 1930s, and it seems like we’re just now really starting to understand what this molecule can do.

Balchem is funding a lot of this work, so I want to give you an opportunity to talk about Balchem as a company and where we’re supporting research in human nutrition, dairy, poultry, and other areas.

Dr. Clay Zimmerman: There are three parts to Balchem as a company. We have a Human Nutrition & Health group, which is quite large. We have the Animal Nutrition & Health group that Scott and I are part of, and we also have what we call the Specialty Products division.

We fund a lot of research across the company, mainly with universities. We do choline research in both the human and animal spaces, and in animal nutrition it’s across species.

We learn something new every time we do it. We don’t fund research just for the fun of it. We’re always discovering something new.

ReaShure is more than 25 years old now, but we continue to fund research, make new discoveries, and learn more about its mode of action.

There’s still a lot we don’t know about what choline is actually doing in animals.

We’ve recently started funding more research in beef, which is a newer venture for us.

We’re now up to 42 published, peer-reviewed papers around ReaShure.

Evolution of Carcass Weights and U.S. Beef Production (44:06)

Scott Sorrell: Brad, before we wind down, are there any other key aspects of your presentation we need to discuss?

Dr. Brad Johnson: I think we’ve covered the highlights of the choline-specific discussion.

But I think it’s important, especially for listeners who are more dairy-focused, to understand how much we’ve shifted the number of days cattle spend in the feedlot and, even more importantly, their final weight.

We’re now calculating break-evens on cattle going out at 1,800, 1,900, or even 2,000 lbs. If we send out a set of steers averaging 1,850 lbs, several individual cattle may weigh more than a ton.

That’s where the term “sweet spot” becomes important. We now have a much bigger sweet spot. We just have to identify the right applications for rumen-protected choline in those animals.

Scott Sorrell: Do you see finishing weights continuing to increase?

Dr. Brad Johnson: I don’t see us going backward.

Around the 1960s through the 1980s, we had close to 45 million beef cows. We’re down closer to 30 million now, yet total pounds of beef production are similar. From an efficiency standpoint, that’s incredible.

We’re very low on cattle numbers. That’s one reason the beef-on-dairy phenomenon has been so important to the beef-production segment. Beef-on-dairy calves have been extremely beneficial for the beef industry.

I don’t see us retracting on hot carcass weight. The trend line has consistently moved upward.

Evaluating Meaningful Differences in Hot Carcass Weight Data (46:45)

Dr. Heather White: Can we talk a little bit about hot carcass weight? Sometimes hot carcass weights are numerically increased but aren’t statistically significant.

I’ve spent a lot of time telling students that we do statistics for a reason, but just because something is statistically different doesn’t automatically mean it’s biologically meaningful. The opposite can also be true. Sometimes something isn’t statistically significant but may still be meaningful in the field, either biologically or economically.

What should we be looking for? What’s a realistic shift in hot carcass weight, and even if it isn’t statistically significant, could it still be meaningful?

Dr. Brad Johnson: That’s a great point.

We were involved in a study at a large commercial research organization where we had 12 pens per treatment, approximately 100 head per pen. We had a 10-lb difference in hot carcass weight, and even with that level of replication, it still wasn’t statistically significant.

Consultants are going to look at a 10-lb difference and say, “Wow.” That’s economically and biologically meaningful.

Because of how we’re feeding cattle today, I think we’ve probably increased the variability around hot carcass weight.

The average hot carcass weight today for a steer is approaching 1,000 lbs. In the 1990s, steer carcasses might have been closer to 700 lbs. As the mean increases, variability around that metric may increase as well.

Yet hot carcass weight is incredibly important because we’re marketing cattle on a grid basis. It’s one of the major economic drivers of gross carcass value.

Scott Sorrell: You talk about the 1990s. I was showing cattle back in the 1970s, and a 1,250-lb animal was a pretty good-sized animal then. It’s crazy how much things have changed.

Future Horizons in Beef Choline Research (49:56)

Scott Sorrell: This has been a fascinating conversation. What are the next steps? You talked about defining the sweet spot, but where would you start with the next phase of beef research?

Dr. Brad Johnson: I’ve made a career out of being deeply invested in the beef industry, both scientifically and from a production standpoint.

What gets me excited is understanding mechanisms of action. Historically, much of my work has centered on growth promotants such as steroid implants and beta-adrenergic agonists.

Here we have an important nutrient or feed ingredient, rumen-protected choline, and we still know relatively little about its full potential.

We know quite a bit about choline as a methyl donor and its effects on lipid metabolism. But when I saw papers focusing on choline working through systems I understand, such as adrenergic receptor signaling systems that profoundly affect muscle growth, that really got me excited.

There’s so much more to learn. If we understand those mechanisms, then we can apply that knowledge to the different phases we’ve discussed, whether that’s feedlot receiving, finishing, or in utero during late gestation.

If choline affects muscle-fiber type, that’s something my lab can address. I’m happy to let Dr. White handle the lipid and methyl-donor work. [laughter]

Dr. Heather White: Happy to take that one.

Dr. Brad Johnson: The more we understand the mechanism, the better we’ll be able to determine where choline fits.

Scott Sorrell: Exciting stuff. I look forward to having you back next year for an update. Maybe we’ll have some new findings by then.

As we close, I’d like each of you to give the audience one or two key takeaways. Clay, as usual, I’m going to start with you.

Sponsor Message: The Impact of ReaShure Precision Release Choline

Announcer: The 42-day transition period is the foundation of a successful lactation. This short window is the launch pad to higher peaks and greater profitability. ReaShure Precision Release Choline from Balchem is the fuel that can help your cows reach their potential.

In mammals, choline is a required nutrient. There are established requirements for expectant mothers, athletes, the elderly, as well as swine and poultry.

During the transition period, dietary choline is extensively degraded by rumen microorganisms, limiting the amount available to the cow when demand is high.

Decades of research have evaluated ReaShure Precision Release Choline and lactation performance. Research at the University of Florida showed cows consuming a transition ration containing ReaShure had higher peaks and produced an additional 4.6 lbs of milk per day compared with cows that did not consume ReaShure.

Research has also investigated effects beyond the cow’s lactation, including the calf developing in utero. Prenatal choline supplementation and calf performance are areas of growing research interest related to developmental programming and epigenetics.

ReaShure is fed for only 42 days of the transition period, but researchers continue to investigate potential benefits for the cow and developing calf.

Expert Summaries and Key Panel Takeaways (55:56)

Dr. Clay Zimmerman: It’s exciting to revisit the beef area again. We took a long hiatus from it, but we think there’s definitely something there. We’ve got exciting data on pieces of this, so I would say stay tuned. I think there’s a lot more to come here.

Scott Sorrell: Absolutely. Heather?

Dr. Heather White: I think that’s a great setup, Clay. For me, it’s about consistency.

We’ve fed this and found the same pathways being influenced in the dairy cow, dairy calves, beef-on-dairy calves, and now in beef animals and beef calves.

It will be really exciting to see, as Brad and others feed it during different phases post-birth directly to the calves, how we can manipulate those same pathways that we seem to be influencing, and perhaps uncover others as well.

Scott Sorrell: Dr. Johnson, final words?

Dr. Brad Johnson: I think it’s always exciting when you have a naturally occurring compound like choline.

The beef industry has come under scrutiny over the years for certain growth-promoting strategies, and we’ve lost compounds because of that.

Whenever you’re dealing with something like choline that people can relate to as a vitamin-like substance, if we can understand its mechanism of action and target its use to benefit animal growth, well-being, and welfare, I think we need more tools like that.

I applaud Balchem for all the research investment already made to understand the mode of action during different phases, predominantly in the transition dairy cow.

I’m excited because the more we learn, understand, and appropriately apply a compound like choline, the more opportunities we may identify.

Scott Sorrell: Exciting stuff. Somebody said “stay tuned,” and I think that’s exactly right.

This has been a very enlightening and exciting podcast. I’ve really enjoyed it. I want to thank all of you for coming along.

To our listeners out there, thank you for joining us. I hope you’re as excited about this as I am. I hope you learned something, had some fun, and I hope to see you next time here at the Real Science Exchange, where it’s always happy hour and you’re always among friends.

Podcast Sign-Off and Balchem Webinar Information (58:35)

Announcer: We’d love to hear your comments or ideas for topics and guests. Please reach out via email at anh.marketing@balchem.com with any suggestions, and we’ll work hard to add them to the schedule.

Don’t forget to leave a five-star rating on your way out.

You can request your Real Science Exchange t-shirt in just a few easy steps. Like or subscribe to the Real Science Exchange and send us a screenshot along with your address and t-shirt size to anh.marketing@balchem.com.

Balchem’s Real Science Lecture Series of webinars takes place on the first Tuesday of every month and covers top research and nutrition topics that can impact your business. We also include small ruminant, monogastric, and companion animal-focused topics throughout the year.

Visit balchem.com/realscience to see upcoming topics and register for future webinars. You can also access past webinars and search for the topics most important to you.

More Podcasts.

View all

Notice

You are now leaving the Balchem Corporation website and linking to a non-affiliated third Party site.

I Understand

Sign up to receive our Newsletter